Domestic Violence – It’s Clearly A Crime – Just Not Clearly Defined In Legal Circles
September 8, 2014

Intimate partner violence includes rape, sexual assault, robbery, aggravated assault, and simple assault by a current or former spouse, boyfriend, or girlfriend. This report presents trends in intimate partner violence by sex, and examines intimate partner violence against women by the victim’s age, race and Hispanic origin, marital status, and household composition. Data are from the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), which collects information on nonfatal crimes reported and not reported to the police from a nationally representative sample of U.S. households.

Take a look at this video and decide what type of crime is being committed?  Is it simple assault, attempted murder, a felony, or a misunderstanding?  Depending upon the officer, the prosecutor, who the person committing the action is or who the individual on the receiving end of the action is, determines how the incident is handled.

http://www.tmz.com/videos/0_ekaflcqq

Females living in households comprised of one female adult with children experienced intimate partner violence at a rate more than 10 times higher than households with married adults with children and 6 times higher than households with one female only.

Females ages 18 to 24 and 25 to 34 generally experienced the highest rates of intimate partner violence.

From 1994 to 2010, about 4 in 5 victims of intimate partner violence were female.

According to The U.S. Department of Justice in a July 1996 National Institute of Justice report to Congress under the Violence Against Women Act:

Within the criminal justice system, data collection is complicated by the division of
responsibilities across many independent entities—law enforcement agencies,
prosecutors, courts, and corrections. Although some local jurisdictions have
established integrated criminal justice information systems, most criminal justice data
are fragmented along operational boundaries. The continued difficulties in obtaining
complete and accurate criminal history records were cited as one indicator of the
inability to track individuals as they move through the criminal justice system or
recidivate for subsequent crimes.

The U.S. Department of Justice 1996 report revealed another eyeopener:

Multi-jurisdictional—multiple State and local agencies
Because of victim and offender mobility, agencies increasingly must be able to share
information across State and local boundaries. There are several Federal and regional
efforts under way to either provide mechanisms to do this or to encourage the
development of these systems. Achieving this goal will take time, however, and many
technical and organizational obstacles will have to be overcome.
One situation where this has been identified as a serious problem is with court
protection orders because officials outside of the originating jurisdictions generally do
not have ready access to the information required for enforcement. In addition,
policies and standards for issuing court protection orders can vary from area to area, making enforcement across jurisdictional boundaries a complex issue for local authorities.

The absence of a national definition of domestic violence causes irregularities in the
inclusion/exclusion of more informal relationships such as current or ex-boyfriends/
girlfriends, roommates, and cohabitants.  For example, Michigan and Kansas
have added a box on their crime incident report forms that officers must mark to
indicate whether an incident was domestic violence related. Other States (e.g.,
Connecticut, New York, and Wisconsin) have separate forms for reporting domestic
violence. The special domestic violence report form enables States to collect offense specific
information that may be more difficult to include in a general crime incident
report form. Use of a separate form, however, does carry the physical and
psychological burden of additional paperwork, which increases the likelihood that
officers will fail to complete or submit a report.

Because domestic and sexual violence victims can face possible reprisals by the
offenders, a heavy burden of embarrassment, and other repercussions, obtaining their
cooperation can be extremely difficult for law enforcement and other agencies. The
act of reporting domestic violence and some sexual violence incidents may be
considered by victims as a last resort or as a way to make an irreparable break in a
relationship. Consequently, the victims may perceive reporting as an admission of
personal failure that they cannot face or believe is avoidable.
Additionally, the problem of adequate training of personnel in handling these cases
often was cited in the project panel discussions and survey responses. As many
jurisdictions are recognizing the seriousness of these offenses, new laws and policies
are being adopted, which in turn may require time to train all relevant staff in new
procedures and to fully implement them.

For all the above reasons, under reporting of domestic and sexual violence can be
more of a problem than for other types of offenses. Although efforts can be made to
overcome some of the factors hindering accurate reporting, some barriers may never
be completely surmounted given the nature of these crimes and the social and
behavioral issues involved.

Because identifying domestic violence crimes may involve consideration of a criminal
act, the relationship between the victim and offender, and the offender’s motive for
committing the act, properly classifying cases can be more difficult than for other
types of offenses. For example, a crime incident that would normally be considered a
property crime (e.g., a burglary, motor vehicle theft, larceny, or vandalism) could be
classified as a domestic violence incident if the perpetrator’s intent is to harass or
intimidate the victim. This may require the investigating officers to go beyond the
facts initially presented for a complaint to its possible underlying circumstances.
An additional complication for data reporting is that some States have not mandated a
specific domestic violence offense with which to charge an offender. In these
instances, the offender is charged with another offense, but his case may be flagged as
a domestic violence case for reporting purposes. Other States have broader family
violence statutes that include domestic violence.

As early as 1930 the Uniform Crime Reporting System has been in existence and all states contribute data into it in one form or another.  The UCRS was not mandatory however.  In 1980 the FBI replaced the old 1930 UCRS with the National Incident Based Reporting System NIBRS.  The new NIBRS is not mandatory for states to enter data.  Whether it’s the old UCRS reporting or the newer NIBRS reporting system, neither system has a clearly defined category for Domestic Violence under Category A or Category B Crimes. 

Time has come for our communities, schools, churches, businesses and families to demand that individuals who commit domestic violence be held accountable for their behaviors.  Men are to honor women as vessels of high value.  Women are to esteem men as one who is her point man or one who is willing to go before her.  Behaviorally, whenever domestic violence presents itself, it is certain that someone is functioning below God’s expectations.  There is never a time when domestic violence should be accepted or explained away in a civilized society.

The “Face” Behind The Face In Mental Illness
September 18, 2013

Columbine, …Fort Hood, Texas….Jonesboro, Arkansas….New Town, Conn…The D.C. Sniper…The Washington, D.C. Naval Yard…

  • A police officer stands at the main gate of the Washington Navy Yard in Washington

WASHINGTON/BOSTON (Reuters) – Rhode Island police warned the U.S. Navy last month that Washington Navy Yard gunman Aaron Alexis had reported “hearing voices,” raising further questions about how he gained security clearance at the complex where he went on a shooting rampage.

What is the common denominator of each place or event listed above?  People with Mental Health Issues that were undetected yet preexisting that ultimately caused the death of innocent victims.  Many man hours, think tanks, security forces and the creation of safety book packs and clothing are attempts to ease the mind of each of us as we so desperately want to be safe.   In the most recent episode of mass killing that took place at The Naval Yard in Washington, D.C., the personality profile of the shooter is almost a photo copy of each one that came before him who committed similar acts.  Conflicting summaries from friends, colleagues, and relatives about the shooter creates an appearance that almost put those who knew the shooter against each other.  At each level of engagement with others, individuals with certain mental illnesses have the ability, at least for a duration of time, to hold themselves together and not reveal the true face of who they really are.  Deception and the ability to manipulate the world around them is critical for day to day existence to individuals with certain mental problems.  There are as many faces behind certain mental illnesses as necessary for the mentally ill individual to survive.  This may be one of the key factors that makes it quite difficult for just one person or one environment to readily pinpoint the larger mental health problem.

Police: Navy Yard shooter experienced paranoia

The D.C. Naval Yard killer time after time exhibited questionable and socially unacceptable behavior.   There was no way how he behaved at home could be clearly conveyed to military personal because Alexis was the buffer between those two worlds of which he was a part.  There was no real way for those who interacted with him socially to communicate with his work world because again he was the buffer between them.  Thus this shooter and all other individuals suffering with certain behavioral mental disorders are also able to make sure that each of their environments never have a real opportunity to merge into one space.  Corporate environments to a larger degree do not look favorably upon people who bring their social or family faces into the work place.  Corporate environments often do not want individuals venting, discussing or seeking help for matters other than what they were hired to do.  Because of the corporate work expectation this becomes a perfect place for individuals with certain mental issues to put on a professional face of having it together, looking the part, talking the part, being admired for their toughness or being admired for being direct or being admired for just being silent and not engaging.  In work environments anger is seen sometimes as one just having a bad day or frustrated with a project, etc.  Only people who work in close day by day sometimes stress environments will begin to notice some abnormalities in how the person responds to frustration and boundaries.  Co-workers begin to use phrases like, he is all business, she is direct and to the point, or he pulls no punches to describe the person.

  • Navy Yard Shooter Aaron Alexis Heard Voices, Experienced Paranoia, Police Report Shows (ABC News)

    ABC News – Navy Yard Shooter Aaron Alexis Heard Voices, Experienced Paranoia, Police Report Shows (ABC News)

a quote from ABC News states the following:

Whether Alexis’s problems actually stemmed from 9/11, his behavioral issues were apparent for years before the shooting.

“I know Aaron had some post traumatic [stress disorder] from being in the military,” his friend Melinda Downs told ABC News. “He went to the VA and they would give him some medicine.”

In addition to Alexis’s claim of PTSD, he struggled to connect with his family and win his father’s approval, Downs said.

The “face” behind the face in many mental illnesses such as discussed in this article manifesting traits of mistrust, the face of insecurity, the face of a sense of entitlement, the face of isolation and the face of anger and the inability to forgive others for injustices goes with the individual whether they are at work, at home or at a social event.  Individuals who share life with individuals suffering from mental illnesses such as narcissism, sociopath, paranoia disorders may sense a low level of discomfort pertaining to the behaviors and comments of such individuals.  Individuals who are narcissistic, antisocial, or paranoid are very careful not to disclose or display all of their internalized emotions for fear that their true face will be made known.

Below are summaries of three mental health disorders that most individuals experience daily at some level but at best scratch their heads in dismay when they try making sense of what just happened right before their eyes.

A. Sociopath Traits –  Promiscuous Behavior, lying as if they are telling the truth, live as a parasite off others, callous, no empathy, no love toward others, nor remorse for actions, arrogant, conning, sense of entitlement

B. Narcissism Traits – Arrogant, self centered, demanding of others, cockiness, manipulative of others, very aggressive, destructive of others character

C. Paranoid – Suspicious of others, feel others have hidden motives, low ability to work with others, social detachment, hostility, carry grudges, very confrontational

The Navy Yard shooter was a practicing Buddhist yet he remained on a road of destruction of others and ultimately himself.  It is not uncommon for people suffering from mental illness and family members to believe the cure for mental illness disorders is religion.

Alexis was also a Buddhist who believed in meditation to relieve stress, she said. He would practice meditation and also encouraged his friends to do so. She said she never would have imagined him shooting innocent people… ABC News

Because many mentally ill individuals do not work with the people they live with, nor do they socialize with with individuals they work with, peoples opinions regarding the exact same person such as the Navy Yard Shooter will almost appear to contradict.  Friends depending upon the level of interaction with mentally ill people may not always know the individual at the same level regarding anger, mistrust, lack of friends, etc.

PublicationsGet booklets, fact sheets, and brochures on mental health topics.

http://www.nimh.nih.gov/statistics/index.shtml

 

The Psychology of ADHD
August 23, 2011

Here’s a strong case for funding public education and maintaining school psychological assessments services:  The majority of children receive their earliest diagnostic testing for ADHD and LD at school and not from the family pediatricians and mental health services before entering school.

The American Psychiatric Association DSM IV-TR reports that 3% to 7% of school age children have Attention Deficit Disorder.  This writer ascribes to genetics,environmental conditions, brain injury, premature delivery and low birth weight as potential causes of ADHD. Within a child’s social environment, this writer also believe that family environmental exposure filled with abuse and lack of structure, criminal behavior or socially inappropriate exposure are contributors to ADHD.

Prevalence of Diagnosis and medication Treatment for ADHD Among Children Aged 4-17 Years - United States, 2003

The more general definition of ADHD centers around a persons inability to pay attention and maintain focus on one specific event.  It is not unusual for individuals with ADHD to act before thinking and in some instances to be overactive as well.  According to The Center for Disease Control there are at least three levels of ADHD:

  • Predominantly Inattentive Type: It is hard for the individual to organize or finish a task, to pay attention to details, or to follow instructions or conversations. The person is easily distracted or forgets details of daily routines.
  • Predominantly Hyperactive-Impulsive Type: The person fidgets and talks a lot. It is hard to sit still for long (e.g., for a meal or while doing homework). Smaller children may run, jump or climb constantly. The individual feels restless and has trouble with impulsivity. Someone who is impulsive may interrupt others a lot, grab things from people, or speak at inappropriate times. It is hard for the person to wait their turn or listen to directions. A person with impulsiveness may have more accidents and injuries than others.
  • Combined Type: Symptoms of the above two types are equally present in the person.
The reported rate of cases in low income homes throughout the United States on average is about 10% higher than homes of middle and upper income families according to the August 2011 Consumer Report News on Health.

The Psychology of Serious Mental Illness
August 15, 2011

The National Survey on Drug Use and Health defines sustained mental illness SMI as a mental, behavioral or emotional disorder that has been diagnosed within the prior year or currently.  This condition must also be void of developmental or substance use disorders.  SMI must also impede or impair routine functioning of ones routine daily events.  The SMI must also meet the criteria found in at least the earlier 4th edition of the DSM IV.

The graph below comes from National Institute of Health (NIH) and it’s division of The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH). 

Serious Mental Illness is found in about 5% of the United States population.  Although the graph indicates a somewhat higher presence among whites and females which is accepted as factual for that population.

On the other hand are African Americans and males less likely to seek clinical help than other reported populations? Does this account for the lower percentages in the findings presented by NIH.